STI 4,975.17 -2.05% Close 2026-11-20
Blue Chips

City Developments at 0.68 times book: is the discount earned?

CDL closed at S$7.21 on 10 November, 0.68 times book and 27.9% below its 52-week high. We weigh whether the discount is deserved.

By DailyMarket SG Research Desk · · 7 min read
Residential blocks in Singapore
Photo: ProjectManhattan, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
6.867.488.118.7390 sessions agoLatest close
City Developments (C09): last 90 sessions -8.8%

The last session told you most of what you need to know about how the market feels about City Developments (SGX: C09). The Straits Times Index rose 1.53% to 5,258.59. CDL went the other way, slipping 0.14% to close at S$7.21. Turnover was 2.38 million shares against a 20-day average of 1.57 million, so the stock was about half again as busy as usual, and it still could not hitch a ride on a strong index day.

Zoom out and the picture is mixed. CDL is up 1.55% over the past month, which suggests some bargain hunting near the floor. But it is down 10.1% year to date, 27.9% below its 52-week high of S$10.00, and only 3.15% above its 52-week low of S$6.99. The share price sits below both its 50-day (S$7.59) and 200-day (S$8.25) moving averages, even with a 14-day RSI of 60, which is neither hot nor cold.

At S$7.21 the stock changes hands at 0.68 times book. That is the sort of number that gets value investors reaching for the spreadsheet. The question is whether the discount is a market error or a fair price for a company with real balance sheet work still ahead of it.

What CDL actually owns

CDL is one of Singapore’s largest private developers, but calling it a developer undersells the complexity. It runs four businesses.

Property development is the biggest earnings engine. In 1H 2026 it produced 67% of group revenue but 84% of pre-tax profit, which tells you both how profitable development is and how lumpy it can be when Singapore projects are recognised on a percentage-of-completion basis.

Hotel operations runs a global portfolio of 165 hotels with around 48,000 rooms, of which 88 are owned. Investment properties cover commercial buildings, malls and the “living” sector (student housing and rental apartments). Fund management sits on top, spanning CDL Hospitality Trusts, IReit Global and private funds, with S$5 billion of assets under management as at 30 June 2026.

Geographically, Singapore is the core. China and Japan are the growth markets. The group is exiting Australia and is reviewing parts of its UK book.

The half-year that changed the conversation

The 1H 2026 results, reported on 13 August, were strong by any measure. Revenue rose 61.1% to S$2.72 billion. Pre-tax profit jumped 188.6% to S$403.8 million. Profit after tax and minority interests (PATMI) more than tripled to S$301.6 million from S$91.2 million.

Property development revenue climbed 166.8%. Hotels grew revenue 6.4% on a 4.9% rise in revenue per available room, and the hotel segment swung from a pre-tax loss of S$84.4 million to a profit of S$42.0 million. Net finance costs fell 47% to S$145 million. The interim dividend was doubled to S$0.06 per share.

Then there is the part that matters more for the discount: gearing. Net gearing rose 4 percentage points to 75% at end-June, driven by government land sales acquisitions and capital expenditure. Management has described that level as high. Liquidity is not the issue, with S$2 billion of cash and S$4.9 billion of committed undrawn facilities, but a 75% gearing ratio in a higher-for-longer rate environment is a conversation the board has to keep having with investors.

Why the market says no

Three things explain most of the discount.

First, leverage. Net finance costs of S$145 million in a single half year is a real drag on earnings that would otherwise flow to shareholders.

Second, the divestment story keeps slipping. CDL has been promising capital recycling for years, and 1H 2026 came and went with little in the way of meaningful gains. Management said during the results call that deals would be weighted to the second half of 2026, and that some significant transactions in advanced stages might only close in 2027. Until cheques clear, the market treats the plan as talk.

Third, book value may not be entirely real. Group CEO Sherman Kwek has said publicly that the group may accept losses on some UK legacy assets, including a roughly S$800 million portfolio that has been flagged for disposal. When management tells you some assets will be sold below carrying value, a discount to book stops looking irrational.

Layered on top is the 2025 public dispute between Kwek and his father, executive chairman Kwek Leng Beng, over control of the company. It was resolved, but governance discounts are slow to fade. The family controls about 49% of the shares, per Bloomberg data cited by VnExpress, which also limits the chance of an outside bid unlocking value.

The valuation, in numbers

Metric Figure
Share price (10 Nov close) S$7.21
Market capitalisation S$6.36 billion
Trailing P/E 7.82
Price to book 0.68
Dividend yield 4.29%
Book value per share (30 Jun 2026) S$10.60
52-week range S$6.99 to S$10.00
Change year to date -10.1%

A 0.68 times book multiple implies the market is writing off roughly S$3 billion of the group’s stated net assets, ballpark, against a book value of about S$9.3 billion. That is a big haircut for a company whose portfolio was last fair-valued at around S$36 billion, up from S$35 billion, according to its chief financial officer on the results call.

We would normally benchmark this against UOL (SGX: U14) and Frasers Property (SGX: TQ5), but we could not verify their current price-to-book figures in time for this piece, so treat the peer comparison as qualitative. Broadly, Singapore developers with heavy investment property and hotel exposure have long traded below book, and CDL’s structure, with hotels, overseas assets and a controlling shareholder, invites a wider discount than a pure Singapore residential play.

What could re-rate the stock

The GET+ plan, unveiled on 28 September, is the clearest catalyst list management has produced. It targets S$5 billion of new investments and S$6 billion of divestments between FY2027 and FY2029, including about S$1.8 billion of hotel sales from a directly held portfolio valued at roughly S$8.6 billion. Over S$6 billion of development cash inflows is expected on top.

The measurable targets are what matter: more than S$1 billion of PATMI from divestment gains, net gearing near 55% by FY2029, a dividend payout of at least 35% of reported profit, and AUM doubling to S$10 billion.

If even most of that lands, three things happen. Gearing falls, which lifts the earnings multiple the market is willing to pay. Realised gains show up in profit, which validates the book value. And a larger fund management platform adds fee income that is not tied to property cycles, which is exactly the kind of earnings that attracts a higher rating.

The risks that keep it cheap

The bear case is not complicated. Divestments at good prices require buyers, and the group has already admitted some sales may happen at a loss. H2 2026 is expected to be weaker than H1 because of project completion schedules, so the next set of numbers may not carry the same momentum. A 75% gearing ratio leaves less room to absorb a downturn in Singapore residential demand or a soft patch in hotel RevPAR.

Two structural drags also persist: the governance overhang from last year’s boardroom fight, and a free float constrained by the family stake. Neither disappears because a strategy deck says so.

The bottom line

CDL is cheap on paper: it trades at 0.68 times book, the hotels generate cash, and the dividend yield is 4.29%. But the discount is not purely sentiment. It reflects genuine leverage, a divestment programme with a patchy delivery record, and an honest admission that some assets may be sold below book.

The way to think about it is as a sum-of-parts story with an execution test. If management hits its gearing target and books the divestment gains it has guided towards, the gap between S$7.21 and book value narrows for fundamental reasons. If the asset sales keep sliding and gearing stays near 75%, the discount is simply the market pricing the risk correctly. Watch the divestment announcements and the full-year numbers, not the strategy slides, for evidence either way.

Sources

  1. CDL unveils GET+ Strategy to accelerate value creation – Sharper…
  2. CDL posts revenue of S$2.7 billion and triples PATMI to S$301.6…
  3. City Developments (SGX:C09) Analyst Ratings